Social Trading vs. Traditional Trading: Key Differences and Benefits

algobotcom

27 September, 2024

Social trading screen
Social trading screen

Social trading platforms are revolutionizing the financial markets. Traders worldwide can now learn from one another, share insights, and collaborate in real-time.

This guide explores how social trading empowers beginners and seasoned pros alike. We also explain the key differences between social and traditional trading, and what best practices to follow before proceeding.

Social Trading vs. Traditional Trading: Key Takeaways

Let’s start with a quick overview of how social and traditional trading differ:

  • Traditional trading involves individual decision-making. On the other hand, social trading allows users to copy or follow experienced investors.
  • Traditional trading requires deep market understanding. In social trading, you rely on other people’s expertise.
  • Traditional trading is more independent, whereas social platforms foster a community-based approach.

In a nutshell, both social and traditional trading have unique advantages. As you explore this guide, we’ll help you determine which approach best aligns with your trading goals.

What is a Social Trading Platform?

Social trading allows traders and investors to connect, share, and collaborate with others. It lets you observe and learn from your peers’ trading behavior. Moreover, you can share your own strategies, insights, and trading decisions in real-time.

Essentially, the concept is built around social networking – but in the trading arena. Typically, traders spend hours researching and honing their skills to make intelligent trading decisions. On the other hand, social trading leverages collective wisdom. It allows novices to take advantage of a professional’s trading experience.

Conversely, seasoned pros can share their knowledge and even earn rewards for their expertise. Modern social trading platforms go further by adding news feeds, forums, polls, and more. This creates a lively, global community where everyone benefits from shared insights.

Key Differences Between Social Trading and Traditional Trading

Social trading has some notable differences from the traditional approach. Let’s explore these characteristics in more detail.

Decision-Making Approach

In traditional trading, decisions are made independently. You analyze market data, develop strategies, and execute trades based on your research and judgment.

For example, a traditional trader might spend hours studying charts, economic indicators, and company earnings reports. Needless to say, this technique leans heavily on individual expertise and can be time-consuming.

In contrast, social trading allows traders to follow and mirror the strategies of more experienced investors. This concept is popularly known as copy trading.

For instance:

  • Social trading platforms often have a list of traders willing to share their strategies.
  • You can choose a trader to copy based on their performance, risk level, chosen asset, etc.
  • You also decide how much to allocate to each trader you copy.
  • Suppose your chosen trader decides to buy a stock.
  • This purchase will be carried out proportionally to your allotted funds in your own trading account.

This seamless replication ensures your portfolio reflects the same trades as the chosen expert.

Knowledge and Learning

Traditional trading often involves a steep learning curve. This process can involve extensive study, practice, and sometimes costly mistakes. For instance, a trader might experiment with different trading strategies and face financial losses before finding a successful approach.

Social trading simplifies this process. It provides access to a trading community with varying levels of expertise. New traders can learn by observing others’ strategies and performance.

Community and Collaboration

Traditional trading is often a solitary endeavor. Networking and collaboration may occur in professional settings like trading desks or investment clubs. For instance, a trader might join a local club to discuss strategies. But more often than not, decisions are made on personal analysis.

Social trading, however, thrives on community interaction and collaboration. As mentioned, with features like copy trading, you don’t have to make any decisions yourself. Additionally, there are other interactive tools at your disposal. Traders can join forums, participate in discussions, and engage with others through social features.

Benefits of Using a Social Trading Tools or Platform

Here are some reasons to consider social trading over the traditional method.

Accessible Trading Strategies 

Perhaps the biggest benefit of social trading is how it makes sophisticated strategies accessible to everyone. By facilitating copy trading, social trading platforms break down barriers to entry.

This eliminates the need for extensive market research and complex decision-making. Beginners can easily participate in the market by leveraging the expertise of others.

Diversify Into Multiple Markets Strategies  

With copy trading comes the advantage of easy diversification. Different trading markets have unique characteristics. As such, developing appropriate strategies for each could take significant time and effort. However, with social trading, you can copy multiple traders with expertise in different assets. This diversification extends beyond just market sectors.

copy trading

You can also spread your investments across various strategies, risk levels, and trade durations. For instance, you might follow a trader focusing on long-term growth stocks. And another who specializes in short-term forex trading. This multi-faceted approach helps mitigate risk, as gains in one market may offset poor performance in another.

Real-Time Trading Insights 

Social trading tools provide insights into market trends and trading activities. For instance, some social trading platforms offer live trade feeds. Users can see the exact positions executed by top traders in real-time.

Users can also view trading statistics and the best-performing strategies. This lets you make informed decisions based on current market conditions and expert actions.

Control and Customization

While social trading offers access to expert insights, the final decision-making process is still in your hands. For instance, you can choose whom to follow and what kind of discussions to join.

Even with copy trading, you get to decide which traders to replicate based on verified data. You can also choose traders based on risk level and set your specific fund allocation. Overall, social trading facilitates a high degree of personalization.

Discussions and Polls

Some social trading platforms feature polls and surveys where users vote on market predictions or asset performance. For example, you might find a poll asking whether a particular stock will rise or fall in the next month. Additionally, you could partake in forums, where traders discuss their market perceptions.

For instance, if there’s a sudden market reaction to an earnings report, the social feed might be flooded with opinions. This information provides a snapshot of collective sentiment. Meaning – traders gauge market expectations and adjust their strategies accordingly.

Why Should Professionals Choose Social Trading Platforms

We’ve discussed the benefits of social trading for beginners. But that doesn’t mean these platforms aren’t suitable for seasoned pros. On the contrary, social trading sites are also worthwhile if you’re a professional; you can expand your reach and generate passive income.

  • Social trading platforms welcome seasoned traders to share their strategies with others. In return, traders can earn rewards. This reward system could be based on profit-sharing or the number of followers you attract. This can create a new revenue stream without requiring additional capital.
  • Additionally, social trading platforms provide access to valuable market insights. This includes real-time sentiment from a global network of traders. Even experts can benefit from seeing how their peers react to market movements.
  • Experienced traders can also save time by copying other professionals. With advanced features, you can customize strategies to fit your goals.

All in all, just like novice traders, professionals can benefit from social trading platforms.

Limitations of Social Trading Tools

Social trading platforms are not without their drawbacks. Consider the following risks before making the transition from traditional trading systems.

Over-Reliance on Others

Traders, especially beginners, may become overly reliant on others. While copying successful traders can yield good results in the short term, it can also stifle a trader’s learning and growth. Trading is a skill developed through experience, analysis, and the ability to adapt to market changes.

Furthermore, markets are highly dynamic. Strategies in one environment may not work in another. Without understanding the reasoning behind a strategy, traders may struggle to adapt when circumstances shift.

community trading

This reliance also creates a false sense of security, as traders may be unaware of the risks involved in the trades they’re copying. Ultimately, social trading tools should complement personal research and learning, not replace them entirely.

Risk of Following Poor Performers

Most social trading platforms offer an overview of their top traders’ performance. However, this metric might not reveal the full picture. For instance, some traders may achieve impressive returns during a bull market.

However, their strategies might be untested in more volatile or bearish conditions. If a trader lacks a proven, long-term track record, followers may unknowingly expose themselves to significant risk.

Delayed Execution

A lesser-known but important limitation of social trading tools is the potential for delayed execution of copied trades. Slight delays can occur from when the lead trader places a trade and when followers copy it. These delays might only be a few seconds, but in fast-moving markets, even a brief lag can lead to significantly different outcomes.

  • For example, in high-frequency or crypto day trading, small price movements can result in large profit/loss differences.
  • By the time a follower’s trade is executed, the market conditions might have shifted.
  • This could lead to suboptimal entry or exit points.
  • This issue is more pronounced in volatile markets with drastic price changes.

Additionally, platforms with many users may experience lags due to server load or other technical factors.  Put simply, followers must be aware that their copied trades may not always perfectly match the original timing or price.

Fees and Profit Sharing

While social trading platforms offer valuable services, they often come with costs that can eat into profits. Many platforms impose fees for copy trading. This would be in addition to standard trading commissions.

Additionally, if you’re a trader sharing their strategies, you must share some earnings with the respective platform. These fees may not seem significant initially. However, they can add up over time, especially if the copied trades only generate moderate returns.

How to Choose Between Social Trading Platforms and Traditional Trading

Here are some points to help you decide on the right trading approach.

What is Your Experience Level?

Choosing between social and traditional trading often comes down to your experience level. Social trading could be a great option if you lack experience analyzing markets or creating strategies. After all, it allows you to learn from experienced traders.

Manual trading

On the other hand, traditional trading could be better for experienced traders who develop their own methods. It’s also the right approach if you enjoy doing in-depth market research and want full control over your trades.

What is Your Time Commitment?

The time you set aside for trading is another factor. Social trading requires less time for analysis and strategy development. This is useful for those with a packed schedule.

Or those who prefer a hands-off approach. However, traditional trading demands more time and effort to research, analyze markets, and execute trades.

What is the Level of Control You Seek?

Social platforms, by design, limit control because their primary function is copy trading. Some platforms offer a degree of customization, but these are typically limited. This lack of control may frustrate traders who prefer to tailor their trading strategies. This limitation also extends to risk management.

With copy trading, you may not have full visibility into your chosen trader’s risk-taking strategies. In contrast, traditional trading allows for complete control over your trades. Whether a day trader or long-term investor, you can fully customize strategies to suit your risk style.

Do you Want to Collaborate?

Social trading platforms are great for market insights and collaboration. Traders can discuss market movements, share technical analysis, and provide feedback on strategies.

This creates a sense of community. This collective knowledge can be invaluable for both beginners and seasoned pros.

Do you Want to Earn Passive Income?

If you’re a professional, social trading can be an extra source of income. You can benefit from profit-sharing agreements, creating a new revenue stream without increasing your trading bankroll. This system allows traders to monetize their expertise and build a loyal following.

In contrast, traditional trading relies solely on individual success, with no opportunity to earn from followers. While it offers full independence, it lacks the passive income potential of social trading.

Top Social Trading Platforms to Consider in 2024

Now that you know how social trading works, let’s discuss the best platforms featuring this service. Below are the top social trading platforms to consider right now.

1. Algobot – Top Al Bot With Integrated Copy Trading 

Algobot is a top-rated automated trading bot. It caters to both beginners and professionals and covers a variety of strategies and markets. For instance, it trades stock, forex, crypto, commodities, indices, and ETFs. Moreover, Algobot features an AI algorithm that adapts to market conditions.

Another unique Algobot offering is its copy trading feature. Rather than copying a human trader, you’ll replicate trades generated by the underlying bot. This way, you can avoid human errors and emotional trading. Moreover, the entire trading process is passive – from market research to risk management. You can also switch between three different risk profiles.

Notably, Algobot has had great success with the German DAX index – with a win rate of 62% to date. To use Algobot’s automated tools, you simply need to connect it to your preferred MT4 or MT5 broker. Additionally, Algobot also has an exclusive Telegram community for its users. This allows the collaboration and sharing of trading insights.

Professional traders can also use Algobot’s exclusive trading indicators via TradingView. Algobot’s forex copy trading costs $50 a month. More advanced features and access to other markets are available for $59.99 a month. You can also get up to 50% off by choosing a yearly plan.

Pros: 

  • Fully autonomous AI-integrated bot
  • Offers copy trading for multiple assets
  • Engage with other Algobot users via Telegram
  • Offers exclusive TradingView indicators
  • Diversify into crypto, stocks, commodities, and indices

Cons:

  • No free trial is offered
  • The profit potential varies depending on market conditions

2. AvaTrade – Create Trading Networks With AvaSocial

AvaTrade is best known for its high security. It holds licenses from nine regulatory bodies from across the world. It supports stocks, commodities, indices, ETFs, and crypto. AvaTrade has also launched a native social trading app – AvaSocial.

This enables users to create or join trading groups, engage in discussions, and share insights. You can also replicate other users’ trades. This is facilitated through third-party platforms like DupliTrade. AvaSocial also offers real-time monitoring and notifications for gains and losses.

Avasocial

You’ll also have access to detailed expert performance metrics for your portfolio. AvaSocial is free for AvaTrade users. There’s also no commission on trading, only the spread. However, the minimum investment required for copy trading via AvaSocial is $2,000.

Pros: 

  • Top social trading platform via an iOS and Android app
  • Copy strategies from other traders
  • Diversify into a wide variety of assets
  • No commissions are charged for trading

Cons:

  • Limited customization for copy trading
  • The minimum investment required is high

3. ByBit – Copy Crypto Trading Strategies With Bots 

ByBit is one of the leading crypto trading platforms. It features a variety of crypto trading bots for grid, martingale, and arbitrage strategies. With its SyncMaster, you can copy an expert trader and replicate their exact orders in your account. You can handpick traders to copy based on their ROI, risk level, and chosen crypto markets.

If you need more control, you can opt for copy bots. These allow you to follow a trader’s strategy; however, you’ll also be able to customize it. You can trade both spot and futures markets on thousands of crypto pairs. Experienced traders can also earn passive income by sharing their strategies.

Bybit copy trading

Another feature is the ByBit CopyTrader Pro. This is exclusive to professionals who want to invest in other traders. However, this requires a higher minimum investment of at least 500 USDT or 10-20% of the portfolio value. ByBit charges no additional fees for copy trading, but standard commissions are applicable. ByBit’s spot commission costs just 0.10% per slide. While derivatives trading costs 0.05%.

Pros: 

  • Copy strategies from other crypto traders
  • Customize strategies via bots
  • Advanced copy trading feature for professionals
  • Supports spot and futures crypto trading

Cons:

  • No social feed for trader discussions
  • Only supports crypto

4. eToro – Multi-Asset Broker With Social Trading Features

eToro is one of the most popular brokerage platforms for social trading. Its social feed is a hub for community interaction. Here, traders can share insights, discuss market trends, and post their trading ideas. eToro also features a CopyTrader function.

You can choose the trader to copy based on their returns, trade duration, and preferred assets. eToro supports stocks, commodities, forex, ETFs, indices, and crypto. It also features top trending traders and those with successful track records. You can copy up to 100 traders simultaneously.

eToro

eToro also has a Smart Portfolio feature where you can diversify into multiple assets at one click. These are categorized based on sectors and themes. Its social trading features are accessible for free. However, you’ll have to consider commissions and spreads. This costs up to $2 for stocks and a flat 1% for crypto. eToro is regulated by multiple financial authorities – making it a secure trading platform.

Pros: 

  • Social feed and community collaboration
  • CopyTrader to mirror other investors
  • Choose traders based on different parameters
  • Offers a variety of asset classes to diversify into

Cons:

  • No customization for copy trading
  • Commission can be as high as 1% for crypto

5. ZuluTradeSocial Trading Platform With Unique Risk Management Features

ZuluTrade is a leading social trading platform that was founded in 2007. The platform’s core feature is copy trading. It allows novices to automatically replicate the trades of more successful traders, known as ‘Leaders’. They’re compensated based on volume or the profit-sharing method.

ZuluTrade uses a proprietary ranking system called ‘ZuluRank’. This evaluates and ranks traders based on their performance, risk management, and consistency. This helps investors make informed decisions when choosing which traders to follow. If you’re a professional, you also have several customization options for manual trading.

ZuluTrade

The platform offers various tradable assets, including forex pairs, stocks, commodities, indices, and crypto. It also provides advanced risk management tools like ZuluGuard, which monitors the performance of followed traders.

ZuluGuard lets you automatically stop copying traders if their performance deteriorates. ZuluTrade can be used with all leading brokers. The platform also has a demo account option. Crucially, ZuluTrade doesn’t charge any fees.

Pros: 

  • Copy ‘Leaders’ to mirror advanced strategies
  • ZuluGuard automatically stops copying when performance drops
  • Supports multiple financial assets
  • No subscription fees

Cons:

  • Profit depends on the chosen trader
  • Trading commissions vary based on the connected broker

6. Naga – Customize Risk Levels for Copy Trading Strategies 

Naga combines traditional trading features with social networking elements. It has a social feed with news, signals, insights, and interaction. Its Autocopy feature lets you mirror strategies from other traders. You can find your preferred trader by comparing their performance track record.

You can allocate a percentage of your funds or a fixed amount per trade. Naga also lets you set your own stop-loss and take-profit limits. This ensures positions align with your goals and risk tolerance. However, you must pay a $0.99 fee for every copied position.

Naga

You can become a ‘Leader’ on Naga by sharing your strategies. The profit you earn depends on your investment amount. Naga also charges commissions on trades – which vary depending on the asset. For stocks, the commission comes to $3 per trade.

Pros: 

  • Autocopy other user’s strategies
  • Customize risk management with copy trading
  • Percentage or fixed amount for fund allocation
  • A lively social feed with market insights

Cons:

  • Passive income for sharing strategies is low
  • Copy trading comes with extra fees

7. WeCopyTrade – User-Friendly Copy Trading Platform

WeCopyTrade is another social platform providing copy trading features. It lets you choose traders to copy based on the number of followers, ROI, and drawdown. You can also customize the risk settings so they align with your trading goals.

WeCopyTrade supports multiple assets, making it a great choice for diversification. This includes stocks, forex, gold, and crypto. The platform also offers detailed statistics of each trade placed. WeCopyTrade works with all MT4/MT5 platforms. Furthermore, a demo account is available – to test the strategies you deploy.

Wecopytrade

However, you need to subscribe to each trader you copy; the price can vary widely. However, if the signals aren’t effective, you can unsubscribe and claim 50% back. Those sharing their trading plans can opt for a monthly or a profit-sharing scheme.

Pros: 

  • Copy traders based on performance
  • Compatible with all MT4 platforms
  • Customization offered for risk management
  • A demo trading account is available

Cons:

  • Subscribing to traders can be costly
  • No social feed or interactive features

8. Vantage – Copy Master Strategies for Leveraged CFDs 

Vantage is a trading platform supporting CFDs for different assets. It lets you trade stocks, indices, ETFs, commodities, and bonds. Depending on the asset, you can also get leverage as high as 500x. Vantage facilitates copy trading from a minimum deposit of $50.

You can copy as many traders as you want and stop anytime. The signal providers on the platform can be filtered based on risk level, ROI, and number of copiers. Anyone can become a signal provider – with a minimum investment amount of $500.

Vantage

Although copy trading is free, you’ll have to pay a commission of around $3 per trade. Vantage also has advanced features necessary for manual trading. This includes sentiment and market analysis, trading signals, economic calendars, and more.

Pros: 

  • Trade CFDs of multiple assets
  • Copy trading supported from $50
  • Leverage of up to 500x is offered
  • Advanced market analytics for manual trading

Cons:

  • Doesn’t support the customization of copy bots
  • Trading CFDs can be risky for beginners

9. CryptoHopper – Crypto Copy Trading With Pump & Dump Protection

CryptoHopper has a wide variety of crypto trading bots featuring different strategies. However, if you don’t know which one to choose, you can also copy other traders. The platform offers detailed accounts of every trader’s earnings, their most traded crypto, the maximum drawdown, and transparent reviews.

Once you decide which trader to follow, you simply need to allocate an amount. CryptoHopper also has a ‘Pump & Dump Protection’ in place. Meaning – there’s a minimum volume requirement before the seller can trade. It also has several trading communities where you can engage with other users. 

CryptoHopper

CryptoHopper lets you use unlimited copy bots for free. It connects with all leading crypto exchanges and supports manual trading. If you want to use trading bots, subscriptions are available from $24.16 a month.

Pros: 

  • Copy trade expert strategies
  • Trade hundreds of crypto pairs
  • Pump & dump protection for copiers
  • Copy bots are available for free

Cons:

  • Limited customization features
  • Only supports only crypto trading

10. Darwinex – Receive Investment for Your Top-Performing Strategies

Darwinex caters to seasoned traders. You can trade stocks, forex, and ETFs via integrated brokers. If you’ve already traded elsewhere, you can import your track record to Darwinex. For top strategies, Darwinex allocates seed capital. In return, you will earn 15% of the profit generated.

Darwinex gives you access to advanced trading tools. There’s also a demo account to test your strategies before risking real capital. Moreover, Darwinex protects your strategies as intellectual property. You’ll also have a dedicated asset manager. As your strategies become more profitable, you can invite hedge funds to invest. However, Drawinex requires a hefty fee of at least $25,000.

Darwinex

On the other hand, if you’re an investor, you can pick your own Darwin strategy. You’ll pay a 1.2% management fee and a 20% commission on any profits. Ultimately, while Darwinex is pricey, it offers some of the best social and trading features in the market.

Pros: 

  • Offer multiple strategies for investors to copy
  • 15% profit-sharing plan
  • Pitch your strategy to hedge funds
  • Protect your strategies as intellectual property

Cons:

  • Best suited for seasoned traders
  • High costs and commissions

How to Balance Social and Traditional Trading?

Combining social and traditional trading approaches can offer you the best of both worlds. This combines the community-driven insights of social platforms with the autonomy and advanced tools of traditional trading.

  • For beginners – By starting with social trading, newcomers can copy the strategies of seasoned traders. Beginners can begin by experimenting with traditional trading via demo accounts. This helps them develop their own strategies while still relying on the guidance of experts.
  • For experienced traders – Professionals can use social trading platforms to analyze market sentiment. They can then use traditional trading to develop bespoke strategies.

Additionally, social trading can also be great for diversification. For instance, if you’re an expert in stock trading but less familiar with forex, you can follow experienced currency traders. This allows you to benefit from expert knowledge while expanding your reach into new markets.

Conclusion

Social trading offers an unprecedented level of collaboration among traders. It’s ideal for beginners, offering the ability to learn from experienced pros. Experienced traders can also benefit from social trading and earn passive income by sharing their insights.

Traditional trading suits those who prefer full autonomy and are willing to invest time in developing their skills. Both approaches offer distinct benefits. The right choice depends on whether you prioritize independence, learning opportunities, or a passive trading experience.

FAQs

What is social trading?

Social trading allows traders to observe, discuss, and share their insights with other users. It also facilitates copy trading, meaning a passive investing experience.

What are the advantages of social trading?

Some benefits of social trading include accessibility, greater transparency, and learning opportunities. It also allows traders to profit from expert trading strategies.

Is traditional trading better for experienced traders?

Traditional trading is better for experienced traders who prefer full control over their investing decisions. However, it requires countless hours in market analysis and trade monitoring.

How does copy trading work?

Copy trading involves replicating the trades of experienced traders automatically. It allows you to benefit from expert strategies without making individual trade decisions.

Does social trading have any risks?

Yes, social trading carries risks, such as relying on the performance of others. It’s imperative to conduct your own research and not depend solely on third-party strategies.

Related Articles

AlgoBot Indicator

We offer an array of advanced trading tools and indicators. However, if you are a beginner, you can also start with our reliable trading signals. This way, you don't have to use complicated trading tools to arrive at decisions. Instead, we will monitor the market and do the legwork to suggest potentially profitable opportunities.

Get Started

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *